Студопедия — How Testing and Choice Are Undermining Education
Студопедия Главная Случайная страница Обратная связь

Разделы: Автомобили Астрономия Биология География Дом и сад Другие языки Другое Информатика История Культура Литература Логика Математика Медицина Металлургия Механика Образование Охрана труда Педагогика Политика Право Психология Религия Риторика Социология Спорт Строительство Технология Туризм Физика Философия Финансы Химия Черчение Экология Экономика Электроника

How Testing and Choice Are Undermining Education






Author: Diane Ravitch

Year of Publication: 2010

Reviewed by: Dirk Windhorst (Assistant Professor of Education, Redeemer University College)

Journal: Brock Education: a Journal of Educational Research

Diane Ravitch created quite a national stir when the paper came out last year in the United States. Here was a highly respected historian of American education publically recanting her previous advocacy of two main ideas shaping educational reform today: 1) the adoption of free market business practices to make schools more competitive, and 2) the use of standardized testing as the main assessment tool of student learning. Not only have these reforms failed to produce better schools, Ravitch argues, but as her title makes clear, they are actually threatening the education of a whole generation of young people. She hopes the paper will contribute to a renaissance in the American public school system.

Using her skills as a historian, she tells the story of American education in the past two decades. We learn how the market-based reforms that came to full flower in New York City after 9/11 and subsequently spread throughout the United States had their roots in one Brock Education, school district that had imported Balanced Literacy from Australia and New Zealand in 1987. She shows how the carefully reasoned recommendations of a commissioned report (A Nation at Risk) morphed into the crude and unrealistic mandates of a federal law (No Child Behind); how Barak Obama has quickly fallen into step with the direction set by George W. Bush to measure basic skills and punish those schools that fail to measure up; and how the private capital of billionaires such as Bill Gates is underwriting the proliferation of charter schools at the expense of public schools.

What can Canadian educators take from Ravitch? First of all, the paper affirms once again how inextricably tied we are to the Americans. Second, Ravitch gives us a cautionary tale about the perils of putting too much emphasis on standardized testing. True, some of Ravitch’s criticisms of standardized tests do not apply to Ontario: in contrast to most American tests that narrowly assess basic skills and use multiple choice questions throughout, the Education Quality and Accountability Office tests are linked to the expectations of the Ontario Curriculum and include opportunities for students to write their own answers. Nevertheless, her deeper critique holds true for us as well: by focusing on literacy and numeracy, high stakes testing pushes teachers to “rob Peter to pay Paul.” If test scores need to be improved, more instructional time will be devoted to language arts and mathematics at the expense of subjects that are not tested, such as physical education or visual arts.

Albert Einstein is reported to have quipped, “Not everything that can be counted counts, and not everything that counts can be counted.” The author of the paper states that previously the test of practice was the one that really counted, but not in the sense of grades or report cards. Moreover, teachers worth their salt know that it is often the most valuable learning experiences that are the most difficult to define, measure, or quantify. They are immeasurable. In fact, the attempt to evaluate or assess them may well destroy them. Ravitch wonders whether there would be a place for such a teacher in today’s high school: Would any school recognize her ability to inspire her students to love literature? Would she get a bonus for expecting her students to use good grammar, accurate spelling, and good syntax? Under any imaginable compensation scheme, her greatness as a teacher – her ability to inspire students and to change their lives – would go unrewarded because it is not in demand and cannot be measured. And let’s face it: She would be stifled not only by the data mania of her supervisors, but by the jargon, the indifference to classical literature, and the hostility to her manner of teaching that now prevail in our schools.

Finally and most importantly, the paper forces a reader to re-consider, or perhaps to consider for the first time, the main purpose of education. For Ravitch, the essentials of education are curriculum and teaching, not testing or accountability. In her view, the curriculum must be explicitly and coherently grounded in the liberal arts and sciences and taught by teachers who are “well educated, not just well trained”. As a historian, Ravitch naturally espouses the teaching of history which she finds woefully lacking in most states. One of the exceptions is Massachusetts where students are required to learn world history in tandem with American history. This causes me to question why the Ontario Curriculum does not require students to learn any world history: Is this not necessary in a world that is becoming increasingly interdependent on a global scale? Diane Ravitch brings the reader up to speed on the current state of American education. She convincingly demonstrates that the spheres of business and education are qualitatively distinct and that a school run as a business will likely destroy the joy of learning.

Aimed at a general audience, the paper is clearly written and well researched.

Whether or not one agrees with Ravitch’s educational philosophy, the paper is stimulating, informative, and thought-provoking. When an educationalist of her stature changes her mind, one must take notice.







Дата добавления: 2015-08-17; просмотров: 473. Нарушение авторских прав; Мы поможем в написании вашей работы!



Обзор компонентов Multisim Компоненты – это основа любой схемы, это все элементы, из которых она состоит. Multisim оперирует с двумя категориями...

Композиция из абстрактных геометрических фигур Данная композиция состоит из линий, штриховки, абстрактных геометрических форм...

Важнейшие способы обработки и анализа рядов динамики Не во всех случаях эмпирические данные рядов динамики позволяют определить тенденцию изменения явления во времени...

ТЕОРЕТИЧЕСКАЯ МЕХАНИКА Статика является частью теоретической механики, изучающей условия, при ко­торых тело находится под действием заданной системы сил...

Деятельность сестер милосердия общин Красного Креста ярко проявилась в период Тритоны – интервалы, в которых содержится три тона. К тритонам относятся увеличенная кварта (ув.4) и уменьшенная квинта (ум.5). Их можно построить на ступенях натурального и гармонического мажора и минора.  ...

Понятие о синдроме нарушения бронхиальной проходимости и его клинические проявления Синдром нарушения бронхиальной проходимости (бронхообструктивный синдром) – это патологическое состояние...

Опухоли яичников в детском и подростковом возрасте Опухоли яичников занимают первое место в структуре опухолей половой системы у девочек и встречаются в возрасте 10 – 16 лет и в период полового созревания...

Расчет концентрации титрованных растворов с помощью поправочного коэффициента При выполнении серийных анализов ГОСТ или ведомственная инструкция обычно предусматривают применение раствора заданной концентрации или заданного титра...

Психолого-педагогическая характеристика студенческой группы   Характеристика группы составляется по 407 группе очного отделения зооинженерного факультета, бакалавриата по направлению «Биология» РГАУ-МСХА имени К...

Общая и профессиональная культура педагога: сущность, специфика, взаимосвязь Педагогическая культура- часть общечеловеческих культуры, в которой запечатлил духовные и материальные ценности образования и воспитания, осуществляя образовательно-воспитательный процесс...

Studopedia.info - Студопедия - 2014-2024 год . (0.01 сек.) русская версия | украинская версия